2016 - 2017 Varsity Softball Roster
14Fiorentino, IsabellaIF/P10Rancho Santa Margarita
21Johnson, MirandaIF10Rancho Santa Margarita
12Lutterloh, MakennaIF12Rancho Santa Margarita
2McClure, MeghanIF12Rancho Santa Margarita
9Mortimer, JuliaOF9Coto de Caza
74Pla, MarisaOF11San Clemente
7Rodriguez, KatieP/IF11Dove Canyon
1Santos, MelanieC/UTL9Rancho Santa Margarita
23Scott, PaigeUTL11Coto de Caza
27Singer, AbbieOF11Ladera Ranch
22Travis, BetsyUTL10Coto de Caza
99Vargas, PaigeP11Mission Viejo
34Wood, EllieOF9Laguna Niguel
5Peters, AkeilaOF10Trabuco Canyon
Cook, KaitlinManager12Mission Viejo
Romero, GabbyManager12Coto de Caza
2016 - 2017 JV Softball Roster
10Allison, MadelineC/IF10Laguna Hills
72Baasche, TatumUTL9Oceanside
4Duffy, ChristinaP/IF10Lake Forest
6Furlong, KendallUTL10Mission Viejo
16Good, JessicaIF9Rancho Santa Margarita
42Leonard, NicoleIF9Mission Viejo
96Loessberg, AbbyIF9Lake Forest
28Pike, HerronP/IF9San Clemente
24Prukop, RachelUTL9Coto de Caza
25Smith, SydneyUTL10Coto de Caza
11Travis, KellyIF10Coto de Caza
55Weekley, KatieP/IF10Trabuco Canyon
20Williams, CadieP/IF9Rancho Santa Margarita
Castilio, WendyManager12Trabuco Canyon


2009 Trinity All League

  • First Team - Meghan Harman
  • First Team - Courtney Hiatt
  • First Team - Amy Letourneau (League MVP)
  • First Team - Catie Monnahan
  • Second Team - Jessie Daulton
  • Second Team - Shainna Groom
  • Second Team - Krista Ury
  • Offensive Player of the Year - Amy Letourneau
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Catherine Mann
  • Scholar Athlete - Krista Ury/ 4.42 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S Value Award - Kellen McNamara

Junior Varsity

  • Offensive Player of the Year - Amy Letourneau
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Michelle Duncan
  • Most Improved - Kathryn Reyes
  • Scholar Athlete - Rachel Dellefield/4.0 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S Value Award - Rachel Dellefield

2008 Trinity All League

  • First Team - Nicki Jacobucci
  • First Team - Nicole Ontiveros
  • Second Team - Kelly Harman
  • Second Team - Meghan Harman
  • Second Team - Cassie Monnahan
  • Honorable Mention - Shainna Groom
  • Honorable Mention - Courtney Hiatt
  • Honorable Mention - Catie Monnahan
  • Honorable Mention - Christine Prochnow
  • Offensive Player of the Year - Nicki Jacobucci
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Cassie Monnahan
  • Scholar Athlete - Nicole Ontiveros 4.44 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Values Award - Christine Prochnow

Junior Varsity

  • Offensive Player of the Year - Amy Alston
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Catherine Mann
  • Most Improved - Blaire Paiso
  • Scholar Athlete - Krista Ury 4.45 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Value Award - Krista Ury

2007 Trinity All League

  • First Team - Meghan Harman
  • First Team - Shainna Groom
  • First Team - Cassie Monnahan (League MVP)
  • First Team - Starr White
  • Second Team - Nicole Ontiveros
  • Second Team - Christine Prochnow
  • Honorable Mention - Ashlee Restadius
  • Offensive Player of the Year - Meghan Harman
  • Co-Defensive Player of the Year - Cassie Monnahan
  • Co-Defensive Player of the Year - Courney Hiatt
  • Scholar Athlete - Nicole Ontiveros 4.57 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Value Award - Starr White

Junior Varsity

  • Offensive Player of the Year - Nicki Jacobucci
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Kayla Shears
  • Most Improved - Helena Oskoui
  • Scholar Athlete - Kamille Paddie 4.41 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Value Award - Kamille Paddie

2006 Varsity Serra All League

  • First Team - Stacia Dopudja
  • First Team - Starr White
  • Second Team - April Glenn
  • Second Team - Kelly Harman
  • Honorable Mention - Cassie Monnahan
  • Honorable Mention - Nicole Ontiveros
  • Offensive Player Of The Year - Nicole Ontiveros
  • Defensive Player Of The Year - Stacia Dopudja
  • Scholar Athlete - Nicole Ontiveros / 4.4 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Value Award - April Glenn
  • Junior Varsity
  • Offensive Player Of The Year - Katie Lubanko
  • Defensive Player Of The Year - Sophia Stamos
  • Most Improved - Kayla Shears
  • Scholar Athlete - Melissa Livingston / 4.1 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S. Value Award - Courtney Hiatt

2005 Varsity Serra All League

  • First Team - Shannon Causgrove
  • Second Team - Cassie Monnahan
  • Honorable Mention - Stacia Dopudja
  • Honorable Mention - April Glenn
  • Honorable Mention - Kelly Harman
  • Honorable Mention - Nicole Ontiveros
  • Honorable Mention - Ashley Restadius
  • Offensive Player of the Year - Nicole Ontiveros / .378 Batting Avg
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Shannon Causgrove
  • Rookie of the Year - Ashley Restadius
  • Scholar Athlete - Nicole Ontiveros / 4.2 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S Values Award - Nicole Ontiveros

Junior Varsity

  • Offensive Player of the Year - Kelli Basin /.482 Avg.
  • Defensive Player of the Year - Melissa Livingston
  • Most Improved - Nikki Daugherty & Katie Lubanko
  • Scholar Athlete - Melissa Livingston/ 4.0 GPA
  • E.A.G.L.E.S Values Award - Tanya Fragnito


Welcome to the home of Lady Eagles Softball. Our history is rich in tradition with league titles, CIF appearances and All League selections. Our program is comprised of special young women that take pride in wearing our school colors and representing our Catholic -Christian philosophy in the spirit of athletic competition.

The mission of our softball program is to train and prepare each athlete to establish a set of goals, and work as a team to achieve each objective, both on the field and in the classroom.

E.A.G.L.E.S. Values

"E"xcellence on the field

"A"ttitude is everything

"G"od is first

"L"oyalty to your team

"E"thics and Integrity internalized

"S"acrifice for each other


Varsity Head Coach John FitzPatrick: Coach FitzPatrick returns for his 13th season as the Varsity Head Coach of Santa Margarita Catholic High School and his 25th year coaching softball. John has an overall record of 171 wins and 149 losses, including 10 trips to the CIF playoffs in his twelve seasons as the head coach. In 2010 the Lady Eagles reached the pinnacle of high school softball in southern California by winning the Division 1 CIF Championship. In 2007 Coach FitzPatrick also led the Lady Eagles to their first league title in the history of the school. John has worked as an assistant coach from 1999-2001 where the Lady Eagles made three consecutive CIF playoff appearances. Coach FitzPatrick has coached for many years on the club circuit and his most recent is with the SoCal A's. Coach FitzPatrick received his bachelor’s degree from Northeastern University and acquired a master’s degree in public policy from Cal State Long Beach. He and his wife Therese have two children, Alycia '01 and Mike '04. His favorite quote is "Anything that doesn't kill you makes you stronger." Coach Fitz can be reached at: fitzpatrickj@smhs.org

Varsity Volunteer Coach Lyn Christensen: Lyn Christensen has been involved in the game of softball as a player and a coach for over 40 years. A three-sport athlete at El Toro HS, Lyn graduated in 1982 and attended Cal Poly Pomona where she played 3B for the D1 Broncos. Lyn feels fortunate to have competed on a team that made the regional playoffs every year she was there, twice moving on to play in the NCAA D1 Women's College World Series (1984, 1985). Lyn began coaching youth softball in 1999 and 2013 marks her 9th year coaching competitive travel ball. Lyn spent many years with the California Cruisers Organization at the 16u and 18G levels. Lyn's 18G Cruisers finished T9 at PGF Nationals, earning a returning berth for 2013. Lyn graduated college with a BS in Business - Finance. She has worked in the Banking Industry as a commercial real estate lender and work-out specialist for 25 years. Lyn and her husband John have been married 25 years, and they have 3 children. Her daughter Kelly '12 who is a graduate of University of Michigan, is an alumni of the Lady Eagles Softball program.

Varsity Assistant Coach Jim Allison: Coach Allison begins his fourth year with Santa Margarita Softball. He was the SM JV head coach in 2014 and also coached softball at Aliso Niguel High School. Jim spent ten years coaching baseball and brings with him a wealth of knowledge. Jim resides in Laguna Hills and with his wife Liz and their two children who also attend SMCHS Emily ‘17 and Madeline ‘19.

Volunteer Assistant Coach Mike Lutterloh – Coach Lutterloh is an experienced coach with over 12 years invested in coaching softball and many more coaching and playing baseball. Mike moved to California from Canada at the age of 9, growing up in Lake Forest, and has lived in Rancho Santa Margarita with his wife Kindra since they were married in 1997. His primary goals are to help the athletes focus on the little things, which he feels are the difference makers, and to create mentally strong athletes who focus on their approach and their reaction to the result…..not just the result. Mike is the head coach of Firecrackers-Lutterloh, a premier, nationally ranked 18 & under travel ball team, and has helped 25 of the 30 Firecrackers-Lutterloh players sign or commit to play softball at some of the most prestigious athletic and academic universities in the country, including Harvard, Duke, Georgetown, Oregon, Cal, Seton Hall, and Notre Dame. Mike and Kindra have three daughters and one son, Makenna, Abigail, Peyton, and Jacob.

Head JV Coach Frank Rizzo: Coach Rizzo is a highly experienced softball coach with over twenty-five years invested in the game. Frank is a native of California, growing up in San Clemente, Ca. He garnered his experience in the men’s fast pitch league, where he spent 28 years playing and administrating the league. Along with his head coaching responsibilities, Frank’s role on SM softball is program development and works together with Coach Fitzpatrick, training and developing new players. His primary goals are to create a positive environment while establishing a strong foundation for SM Softball. Frank is the former head coach of Concordia University as well as JSerra High School. He also assisted at San Clemente High School and Saddleback College. Frank lives with his wife Tami and they have two daughters, Jenifer and Sara.

Assistant JV Coach Melissa Kohlmann: Coach Mel is an experienced softball coach and player. She earned a full scholarship to Creighton University her freshman year and then transferred to Point Loma Nazarene University for the next three years. As a college athlete she had a career batting average of .416, ERA of 1.12, and holds the school records for home runs and rbi’s. After college, she played professional softball overseas in Germany, and then returned to the PLNU softball program as an assistant coach for a year. After receiving an MAT from USC, Coach Mel was later an assistant coach and head coach for La Habra High School. Mel joined the SM staff as a Math teacher in 2015, and hopes to be a positive role model for her students, and players in the softball program. She was recently married and lives with her husband, Scott.



2017 SMCHS Varsity Softball Schedule 23 - 5 | 5 - 3
Saturday2/25/2017WoodbridgeLaguna Hills11:00 AMW 5-0
Saturday2/25/2017Laguna HillsLaguna Hills3:15 PMW 14-2
Tuesday2/28/2017Trabuco HillsTrabuco Hills HS3:15 PMW 6-0
Thursday3/2/2017IrvineSM Field3:30 PMW 5-0
Saturday3/4/2017Dana HillsSM Field9:00 AML 4-3
Saturday3/4/2017San ClementeSM Field11:00 AMW 7-2
Tuesday3/7/2017Laguna HillsSM Field3:15 PMW 8-0
Thursday3/9/2017TesoroSM Field3:15 PMW 12-1
Monday3/13/2017El ModenaAlicia Park3:15 PMW 5-0
Tuesday3/14/2017Laguna HillsLaguna Hills3:15 PMW 3-0
Wednesday3/15/2017NorthwoodNorthwood3:15 PMW 6-1
Thursday3/16/2017Capo ValleyCapo Valley3:15 PML 6-1
Tuesday3/21/2017Aliso NiguelAliso Niguel3:15 PMW 3-2
Thursday3/23/2017Capo ValleySM Field3:15 PMW 4-3
Saturday3/25/2017San Juan HillsYorba Park9:00 AMW 1-0
Saturday3/25/2017TroyYorba Park3:15 PMW 6-5
Tuesday3/28/2017Orange LutheranSM Field3:15 PML 5-3
Wednesday3/29/2017Hood River, Ore.SM Field4:00 PMW 4-1
Friday3/31/2017JSerraJSerra HS3:15 PMW 4-0
Saturday4/1/2017El SegundoYorba Park6:30 PMW 12-4
Saturday4/1/2017ValenciaYorba Park8:15 PMW 5-3
Friday4/7/2017Mater DeiSM Field3:15 PMW 4-3
Tuesday4/11/2017RosaryFullerton JC3:15 PMW 5-3
April 13 - 20 EASTER BREAK
Tuesday4/25/2017Orange LutheranOrange Lutheran3:15 PML 7-0
Friday4/28/2017JSerraSM Field3:15 PMW 10-0
Thursday5/4/2017Mater DeiThorton Park, Santa Ana3:15 PML 8-2
Tuesday5/9/2017RosarySM Field3:15 PMW 13-9
Thursday5/18/2017CIF 1st Rd. vs. MillikanSM Field3:15 PMW 4-2
Tuesday5/23/2017CIF 2nd Rd. WarrenWarren HS3:15 PMW 8-0
Thursday5/25/2017CIF Qtr. Final vs. Riverside PolySM Field2:15 PM
2017 SMCHS JV Softball Schedule
Tuesday2/28/2017Trabuco HillsSM Field3:15 PM
Thursday3/2/2017IrvineIrvine HS3:30 PM
Tuesday3/7/2017Laguna HillsLaguna Hills HS3:15 PM
Thursday3/9/2017TesoroTesoro HS3:15 PM
Friday3/10/2017Northwood TournamentTBATBA
Saturday3/11/2017Northwood TournamentTBATBA
Mon - Thurs.3/13/2017Saddleback TournamentAlicia ParkTBA
Friday3/17/2017Northwood TournamentTBA
Saturday3/18/2017Northwood TournamentTBA
Tuesday3/21/2017Aliso NiguelSM Field3:15 PM
Thursday3/23/2017Capo ValleyCapo Valley3:15 PM
Friday3/24/2017San Juan Hills
(Savanna Tournament)
SM Field3:15 PM
Saturday3/25/2017Savanna TournamentYorba ParkTBA
Tuesday3/28/2017Orange LutheranOrange Lutheran HS3:15 PM
Thursday3/30/2017Dana HillsDana Hills3:15 PM
Friday3/31/2017Savanna TournamentTBA
Saturday4/1/2017Savanna TournamentYorba ParkTBA
Wednesday4/5/2017Huntington BeachTBATBA
Friday4/7/2017Mater DeiThorton Park, Santa Ana3:15 PM
April 13 - 20_ EASTER BREAK
Tuesday4/25/2017Orange LutheranSM Field3:15 PM
Thursday4/27/2017Mater DeiThorton Park, Santa Ana3:15 PM
Friday4/28/2017Huntington BeachTBATBA
Thursday5/4/2017Mater DeiSM Field3:15 PM


Summer Camp

Fee: $75

WHO: Incoming Freshmen Camp (7th & 8th grade may also attend)

WHERE: SMCHS High School Softball Field

WHEN: Monday, August 7, 2017 | 10 AM – 1 PM

Get ready for our Summer Softball Camp instructed by Head Coach John FitzPatrick, along with members of the SM Softball Staff. They will work with campers to strengthen their fundamentals and increase their knowledge of the game. They will work on infield, outfield, pitching, catching, hitting, base running, conditioning and more. Campers will need to bring their glove, a bat and cleats, and any special equipment they might need, i.e. catching gear. Each camper will receive a tee-shirt and a snack will be provided each day. Incoming freshmen are encouraged to attend.

RSVP and Questions: sportscamps@smhs.org

Online Registration

Trinity League Locations

  • Jserra High School

26351 Junipero Serra Road

San Juan Capistrano, 92675



5 south; Exit Junipero Serra Road; Turn Right

  • Mater Dei High School

1202 West Edinger Avenue

Santa Ana, 92707



405 North; Exit Bristol; Right on Bristol; School is on the corner of Bristol and Edinger

  • Orange Lutheran High School

2222 North Santiago Blvd.

Orange, 92867



5 North to 55 North; Exit E. Katella Avenue, Turn Right;

Turn Left on N. Wanda Road which turns into N. Santiago Blvd.

  • Rosary High School

1340 North Acacia

Fullerton, 92831



5 North to 57 North; Exit Nutwood, Left on Nutwood; Right on Acacia, School is on the Right

  • Servite High School

1952 West La Palma Avenue

Anaheim, 92801



5 North; Exit Brookhurst/La Palma; Right on Brookhurst/La Palma, School is on the Right (1/4 mile)

  • St. John Bosco High School

13640 South Bellflower

Bellflower, 90706



405 North to 605 North; Exit Rosecrans Avenue; Left of Rosecrans; Right on Bellflower; School is on the Right

  • Saddleback College

All SMCHS Varsity Home Football Games

28000 Marguerite Parkway

Mission Viejo, 92692


5 South to Avery Parkway; make a Left; entrance is on the Left; go to the stop sign and make a Right to the football stadium; parking is on the Left.

Powered by Finalsite